For IndividualsFor Educators
ExpertMinds LogoExpertMinds
ExpertMinds

Ace your certifications with Practice Exams and AI assistance.

  • Browse Exams
  • For Educators
  • Blog
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Cookie Policy
  • Support
  • AWS SAA Exam Prep
  • PMI PMP Exam Prep
  • CPA Exam Prep
  • GCP PCA Exam Prep

© 2026 TinyHive Labs. Company number 16262776.

    PracticeACCAACCA AA — Audit and Assurance Practice Exam 3Question 10
    Easy2 marksMultiple Choice
    Audit evidenceWritten RepresentationsAudit EvidenceISA 580

    ACCA · Question 10 · Audit evidence

    CASE 2: GREENYIELD AGRI CO-OP
    GreenYield Agri Co-op is a large agricultural cooperative specializing in organic crop production and livestock. You are the audit senior. The year-end is 31 December 2025. GreenYield uses an independent agronomist to value its biological assets. During the year, a new computerized inventory system was implemented. The audit team is planning the inventory count attendance and evaluating the reliability of the agronomist's report.

    Management has informed you that a specific herd of cattle is intended to be sold in January 2026 at a premium price due to a special organic certification. You require a written representation regarding management's intent. What is the primary limitation of this written representation?

    Answer options:

    A.

    It is not legally binding and therefore cannot be included in the audit file.

    B.

    It does not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence on its own and must be corroborated.

    C.

    It can only be signed by the independent agronomist, not management.

    D.

    It is only valid if obtained before the financial year-end.

    How to approach this question

    Recall the fundamental rule of ISA 580 regarding the evidentiary value of written representations.

    Full Answer

    B.It does not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence on its own and must be corroborated.✓ Correct
    While written representations are necessary audit evidence (especially regarding management's intentions, which are hard to prove otherwise), ISA 580 explicitly states they do not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence on their own. The auditor must still seek corroborative evidence (e.g., reviewing the organic certification, checking post year-end sales agreements).

    Common mistakes

    Believing that a management representation letter is a 'get out of jail free' card that replaces the need for substantive testing.
    Question 09All questionsQuestion 11

    Practice the full ACCA AA — Audit and Assurance Practice Exam 3

    18 questions · hints · full answers · grading

    Sign up freeTake the exam

    More questions from this exam

    Q01CASE 1: NEXUSCLOUD LTD NexusCloud Ltd is a rapidly growing SaaS (Software as a Service) technolog...MediumQ02CASE 1: NEXUSCLOUD LTD NexusCloud Ltd is a rapidly growing SaaS (Software as a Service) technolog...EasyQ03CASE 1: NEXUSCLOUD LTD NexusCloud Ltd is a rapidly growing SaaS (Software as a Service) technolog...MediumQ04CASE 1: NEXUSCLOUD LTD NexusCloud Ltd is a rapidly growing SaaS (Software as a Service) technolog...EasyQ05CASE 1: NEXUSCLOUD LTD NexusCloud Ltd is a rapidly growing SaaS (Software as a Service) technolog...Medium
    View all 18 questions →