Medium25 marksExtended Response
Treasury and Advanced Risk Management TechniquesTreasury ManagementInterest Rate SwapsInterest Rate OptionsCollars

ACCA · Question 02 · Treasury and Advanced Risk Management Techniques

SECTION B: ADVISORY REPORT

This question is based on the Heavy Manufacturing and Aerospace sector.

AeroForge Ltd is a specialized manufacturer of aerospace components. The company has recently secured a major contract to supply landing gear for a new commercial airliner. To finance the expansion of its manufacturing plant, AeroForge will take out a $50 million loan in exactly 6 months' time. The loan will be for a period of 5 years, with interest payable annually at a floating rate of SOFR + 1.8%.

The current Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) is 4.0%. The Treasury team at AeroForge is highly concerned that interest rates will rise over the next 6 months, severely impacting the profitability of the new contract.

The company's bank has offered the following hedging instruments:

  1. Interest Rate Swap:
    AeroForge can enter into a swap starting in 6 months. The bank is quoting a swap rate where AeroForge pays a fixed rate of 4.5% and receives SOFR.

  2. Interest Rate Options (Collar):
    AeroForge can purchase an interest rate cap at a strike rate of 4.8% for a premium of 0.6% (payable upfront). To offset this cost, AeroForge can sell an interest rate floor at a strike rate of 3.5% for a premium of 0.4% (receivable upfront).

Assume that in 6 months' time, SOFR could either rise to 5.5% or fall to 3.0%.

Requirements:
(a) Calculate the effective annual interest rate that AeroForge will pay under BOTH the Interest Rate Swap and the Interest Rate Collar, under the two scenarios where SOFR in 6 months is 5.5% and 3.0%. (15 marks)

(b) Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of using an Interest Rate Collar compared to a Swap in this scenario. Furthermore, briefly discuss whether AeroForge's treasury department should operate as a cost center or a profit center. (10 marks)

How to approach this question

Step 1: For the swap, remember the effective rate is always the Fixed Swap Rate + the company's borrowing spread (4.5% + 1.8% = 6.3%). Prove this by showing the cash flows for the loan and the swap separately. Step 2: For the collar, calculate the net premium first. Then, for each scenario, determine if the Cap is exercised (if SOFR > Cap strike) or if the Floor is exercised (if SOFR < Floor strike). Add the loan interest, the option payoff, and the premium. Step 3: Compare the outcomes to discuss advantages. Step 4: Define cost vs profit center and apply it to a manufacturing company.

Full Answer

Interest rate swaps fix the borrowing cost completely, providing certainty but removing any benefit from falling rates. A collar limits the maximum interest rate (via the cap) while reducing the upfront premium cost by giving up some of the benefit of falling rates (via selling the floor).

Common mistakes

Students often forget to include the company's borrowing spread (+1.8%) when calculating the swap rate. Another common error is subtracting the floor payment instead of adding it to the company's costs when SOFR falls below the floor strike.

Practice the full ACCA AFM — Advanced Financial Management Practice Exam 3

3 questions · hints · full answers · grading

More questions from this exam