Question 1

SECTION B: ADVISORY REPORT

Report to the Directors of AgriYield PLC

EXHIBIT 1: AGRIYIELD PLC EXPANSION PLANS
AgriYield PLC is a UK-resident company specializing in agricultural technology and genetically modified drought-resistant seeds. The company is highly profitable and pays UK Corporation Tax at the main rate of 25%. The Board of Directors has decided to expand operations into 'San Lorenzo', a rapidly developing non-UK jurisdiction.

EXHIBIT 2: SAN LORENZO TAX REGIME AND OPERATIONS
San Lorenzo has a flat corporate income tax rate of 15%. There is no double taxation treaty between the UK and San Lorenzo. 
The new operation will manufacture and sell seeds locally in San Lorenzo. The intellectual property (patents) for the seeds will remain owned by AgriYield PLC in the UK, and the San Lorenzo operation will pay a royalty for their use. 
The Board expects the San Lorenzo operation to generate trading losses of £500,000 in Year 1, followed by annual taxable profits of £2,000,000 from Year 2 onwards.

REQUIREMENTS:
Prepare a memorandum for the Board of Directors of AgriYield PLC which:
(a) Evaluates the UK tax consequences of structuring the San Lorenzo operation as an overseas branch versus a wholly-owned overseas subsidiary. Your evaluation must specifically address the treatment of the Year 1 losses and Year 2 profits, and the impact of making a branch exemption election. (12 marks)
(b) Explains the application of the UK Controlled Foreign Company (CFC) rules if the subsidiary structure is chosen, detailing how the CFC charge is calculated and whether any entity-level exemptions might apply to the San Lorenzo subsidiary. (8 marks)
(c) Briefly outlines the UK Transfer Pricing implications regarding the royalty payments for the use of the patented seeds, assuming the subsidiary structure is chosen. (5 marks)

Accepted Answer

Structure your memo clearly. For part (a), contrast the immediate loss relief of a branch against the lower long-term tax rate of a subsidiary. Explicitly mention the mechanics of the branch exemption election (it's irrevocable and applies to all branches). For part (b), define a CFC, explain the tax exemption threshold (75% of UK tax), and apply the numbers (15% vs 18.75%) to prove the exemption fails. For part (c), define the arm's length principle and explain the direction of the adjustment (increasing UK taxable profits).

Question 2

What mistakes do candidates make on this ACCA question?

Accepted Answer

Students often state that a branch exemption election should be made immediately. In reality, if initial losses are expected, it is better to delay the election so the losses can be utilized in the UK. Another common error is failing to actually calculate the 75% threshold for the CFC tax exemption.

How to approach this question

Full Answer

Common mistakes

Practice the full ACCA ATX — Advanced Taxation Practice Exam 1

More questions from this exam