Question 1

SECTION B: ADVISORY REPORT

This question is worth 25 marks.

You are a tax advisor. Your client, Clara (aged 68), is a sole trader who has run 'Thorne Farms' for the last 30 years. She is reviewing her estate planning and business structure.

Clara's current assets include:
- 500 acres of agricultural land, farmed in-hand by Clara.
- A large farmhouse situated on the land, which Clara occupies. It is the center of the farming operations.
- Three cottages located on the edge of the farm, which are let out on assured shorthold tenancies to unconnected third parties.
- Farm machinery and working capital.

Clara is considering two major transactions:

Transaction 1: Partnership Formation
Clara wishes to bring her daughter, Sarah, into the business. Clara will transfer 40% of the farming business (including the land, machinery, and working capital, but excluding the let cottages) to Sarah, creating a formal partnership. Sarah will not pay any cash for this share.

Transaction 2: Land Sale and Reinvestment
Following the partnership formation, the partnership plans to sell 50 acres of the agricultural land to a commercial developer for £2 million, realizing a substantial capital gain. Within 12 months, the partnership intends to reinvest the entire £2 million proceeds into purchasing a new commercial warehouse (to be let out to a logistics company) and upgrading the farm machinery.

REQUIREMENTS:

Prepare a report for Clara advising on:

(a) The Inheritance Tax (IHT) implications of her current estate, specifically evaluating the availability of Agricultural Property Relief (APR) and Business Property Relief (BPR) on the farmhouse, the 500 acres of land, and the three let cottages. (10 marks)

(b) The Capital Gains Tax (CGT) and Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) implications of forming the partnership with Sarah (Transaction 1). (7 marks)

(c) The CGT implications of selling the 50 acres of land and the availability of Rollover Relief on the proposed reinvestments (Transaction 2). (8 marks)

Accepted Answer

Step 1: Structure the response as a formal report to the client.
Step 2: For Part (a), analyze each asset separately. Apply the 'character appropriate' test for the farmhouse. Distinguish between agricultural value (APR) and market value (BPR). Identify the cottages as investments.
Step 3: For Part (b), recognize the connected party rules for CGT and apply s.165 holdover relief. For SDLT, mention the specific partnership rules (Schedule 15) and the Sum of the Lower Proportions.
Step 4: For Part (c), evaluate the qualifying nature of the old asset (land = qualifying) and the new assets. Crucially, identify that a let warehouse is an investment, not a trading asset, and therefore fails the rollover relief conditions.

Question 2

What mistakes do candidates make on this ACCA question?

Accepted Answer

Assuming the let cottages qualify for BPR under the Balfour matrix. While possible in a large estate, as a sole trader, they are usually separate investments. Another common error is assuming any commercial property qualifies for rollover relief, forgetting it must be used in the taxpayer's own trade.

How to approach this question

Full Answer

Common mistakes

Practice the full ACCA ATX — Advanced Taxation Practice Exam 5

More questions from this exam