Medium2 marksStructured
The rate and extent of chemical changeHigherrates of reactionexperimental errorgas collection

AQA GCSE · Question 09.1 · The rate and extent of chemical change

Water50 cm³measuringcylinderStopperConical flaskSulfuric acidZinc

A student investigated the rate of the reaction between zinc and sulfuric acid. The equation for the reaction is: Zn(s) + H₂SO₄(aq) → ZnSO₄(aq) + H₂(g). Figure 10 shows the apparatus.
The method used is:

  1. Pour 50 cm³ of sulfuric acid into the conical flask.
  2. Add excess zinc to the conical flask.
  3. Insert the stopper and start a timer.
  4. Measure the volume of hydrogen collected in the 50 cm³ measuring cylinder every 20 seconds for 180 seconds.

Explain why the volume of hydrogen collected in the 50 cm³ measuring cylinder is less than the volume of hydrogen produced.

How to approach this question

Consider the experimental setup and procedure. Where could some of the hydrogen gas be "lost" so that it is not collected in the measuring cylinder? 1. Think about the time between step 2 (adding zinc) and step 3 (inserting stopper). What is happening during this time? 2. Look at how the gas is collected. It is bubbled through water. What property of gases might cause a small loss here? 3. Are there any other potential issues with the apparatus itself?

Full Answer

Any two from: - Some gas escapes between adding the zinc and inserting the stopper. - Hydrogen gas is slightly soluble in water, so some will dissolve in the water in the trough. - Some gas may leak from the apparatus if it is not sealed properly.
There are several potential sources of error in this experimental setup that would lead to the collected volume of gas being less than the actual volume produced by the chemical reaction. 1. **Gas lost at the start:** The reaction between zinc and sulfuric acid starts immediately upon contact. There is a delay between adding the zinc (step 2) and inserting the stopper (step 3). During this time, hydrogen gas is being produced and escaping from the open neck of the conical flask into the room, so it is not collected. 2. **Solubility of gas:** Hydrogen is only slightly soluble in water, but some of the gas produced will dissolve in the water in the trough and measuring cylinder instead of displacing it. This dissolved gas is not measured as part of the collected volume. 3. **Leaks:** If the stopper is not a tight fit, or if there are any other leaks in the apparatus (e.g., around the delivery tube), some gas could escape instead of being channelled into the measuring cylinder.

Common mistakes

✗ Stating human errors like "misreading the scale" - the question asks for reasons inherent to the method/apparatus. ✗ Stating that the reaction is not complete (the question says excess zinc is used, so the acid will be fully reacted). ✗ Giving physically incorrect reasons, e.g., "hydrogen reacts with water".

Practice the full AQA GCSE Chemistry Higher Tier Paper 2

48 questions · hints · full answers · grading

More questions from this exam