Medium6 marksExtended Response
How the economy worksGeneralMarket FailureExternalitiesSocial Benefit

AQA GCSE · Question 25 · How the economy works

Explain two possible external benefits of HS2.

How to approach this question

1. Define or show understanding of 'external benefits' (positive effects on third parties). 2. Identify a first external benefit, such as reduced road congestion. Explain *why* this is an external benefit – who benefits and why are they a third party? 3. Identify a second, distinct external benefit, such as economic regeneration. Again, explain why this is an external benefit and who the third-party beneficiaries are.

Full Answer

External benefits are positive spillover effects on third parties. Two possible external benefits of HS2 are: 1. Reduced road congestion. By providing a fast and efficient alternative to driving, HS2 could encourage people to switch from using cars to using the train, especially for long-distance journeys between major cities. This would lead to fewer cars on motorways like the M1 and M6. The external benefit is enjoyed by the remaining road users (third parties), who would experience less traffic, faster journey times, and potentially fewer accidents. This benefit is not captured in the ticket price paid by the train passenger. 2. Economic regeneration in areas around new stations. The construction of new HS2 stations in cities like Birmingham and Manchester can act as a catalyst for wider urban regeneration. This can attract new businesses, shops, and hotels to the area, creating jobs and improving the local environment. The benefits of this regeneration are enjoyed by local residents and businesses (third parties), not just the HS2 company or its passengers. This can lead to an increase in property values and local economic growth.
External benefits, or positive externalities, occur when the consumption or production of a good causes a benefit to a third party. For HS2: - **Reduced Congestion:** This is a classic external benefit of public transport. Every person who takes the train instead of driving reduces the number of cars on the road, which benefits all other drivers. - **Regeneration:** Large infrastructure projects often spur development in the surrounding areas. This creates a more pleasant environment and economic opportunities for people who may never use the train itself. - **Environmental Benefits:** A shift from cars and domestic flights to electric trains can reduce carbon emissions and air pollution, benefiting society as a whole. - **Increased Labour Mobility:** While a private benefit for the worker and firm, it can also have external benefits by boosting the overall productivity and dynamism of the national economy.

Common mistakes

Describing private benefits (e.g., 'faster journey times for passengers') instead of external benefits. The key is to identify the benefit to a *third party*.

Practice the full AQA GCSE Economics Paper 1

27 questions · hints · full answers · grading

More questions from this exam