Hard15 marksExtended Response
How the economy worksGlobalisationLEDCsMNCsInternational Trade

AQA GCSE · Question 26 · How the economy works

Using Items A and B and your own economic knowledge, discuss whether increasing globalisation is beneficial for people in less economically developed countries.

Justify your answer.

How to approach this question

1. **Introduction:** State that globalisation has both benefits and drawbacks for LEDCs. 2. **Argument for (Beneficial):** Use Item B to discuss the benefits. Focus on 'job creation' by MNCs. Explain how this FDI can lead to higher incomes, skills transfer, and economic growth. Use examples from Table 6 (e.g., an MNC like Apple investing in Vietnam). You can also bring in the concept of free trade from Item A, explaining how it helps LEDCs export goods. 3. **Argument against (Not Beneficial):** Use Item B to discuss the drawbacks. Focus on MNCs not generating the hoped-for benefits. Explain the problems of labour exploitation (low wages, poor conditions) and 'tax avoidance'. Explain how this limits the host country's development. You can also add points about environmental damage and competition for local firms. 4. **Conclusion/Justification:** Provide a justified conclusion. Weigh up the arguments. Is it beneficial overall? Argue that the outcome is not automatic and depends on how globalisation is managed. Conclude that it *can* be beneficial, but only if safeguards are in place to mitigate the negative effects.

Full Answer

This high-mark question requires a balanced evaluation of globalisation's impact on LEDCs. **Potential Benefits:** - **FDI and Job Creation:** As Item B states, MNCs create jobs, which can be a route out of poverty. - **Technology and Skills Transfer:** MNCs bring modern production techniques and train the local workforce. - **Increased Exports:** Free trade (Item A) allows LEDCs to access richer markets, boosting their export revenues. - **Economies of Scale:** Specialisation and trade allow for greater efficiency. - **Consumer Benefits:** Access to a wider variety of cheaper imported goods. **Potential Drawbacks:** - **Exploitation of Labour:** Low wages, poor working conditions, use of child labour. - **Tax Avoidance:** As mentioned in Item B, MNCs may use transfer pricing and other schemes to avoid paying taxes in the host country, limiting government revenue for development. - **Environmental Damage:** MNCs may exploit lax environmental laws. - **Competition for Domestic Firms:** Small local firms may be driven out of business. - **Repatriation of Profits:** MNCs may send profits back to their home country rather than reinvesting them locally. A strong conclusion will not give a simple 'yes' or 'no' but will argue that the outcome is contingent on effective governance and regulation to harness the benefits and mitigate the costs.

Common mistakes

Providing a one-sided argument. Not using the information from both Item A and Item B. Simply listing points without developing them with economic reasoning. A weak or unjustified conclusion.

Practice the full AQA GCSE Economics Paper 2

29 questions · hints · full answers · grading

More questions from this exam