Easy1 markExtended Response
Ratio Proportion and Rates of ChangeHigherRatio Proportion and Rates of ChangeProblem SolvingRounding
AQA GCSE · Question 07.2 · Ratio Proportion and Rates of Change
On a school trip, one teacher is needed for every group of 10 or fewer students. 72 students want to go on the trip. Lexi tries to work out how many teachers are needed.
Her working is:
72 ÷ 10 = 7.2
7 teachers are needed.
What is wrong with her answer?
On a school trip, one teacher is needed for every group of 10 or fewer students. 72 students want to go on the trip. Lexi tries to work out how many teachers are needed.
Her working is:
72 ÷ 10 = 7.2
7 teachers are needed.
What is wrong with her answer?
How to approach this question
1. Analyse Lexi's calculation: 72 ÷ 10 = 7.2. This is correct.
2. Analyse her conclusion: "7 teachers are needed".
3. Think about the context of the problem. Can you have a fraction of a teacher?
4. If 7 teachers take 10 students each, how many students are supervised? How many are left over?
5. Does the leftover group of students need a teacher according to the rule?
6. Explain why her conclusion is wrong and what the correct number should be.
Full Answer
You cannot have 0.2 of a teacher. The result of the division, 7.2, means that 7 teachers can supervise 70 students, but there are still 2 students left over. A teacher is needed for this remaining group of 2 students. Therefore, you must round 7.2 up to the next whole number, which is 8. So, 8 teachers are needed.
Lexi's calculation 72 ÷ 10 = 7.2 is mathematically correct, but her interpretation of the result in the context of the problem is wrong.
The result 7.2 means that 7 full groups of 10 students can be formed, with 0.2 of a group left over. This remainder represents 2 students (0.2 × 10 = 2).
The rule states that "one teacher is needed for every group of 10 or fewer students".
The 7 full groups require 7 teachers.
The remaining group of 2 students, although smaller than 10, still requires one teacher.
Therefore, the total number of teachers needed is 7 + 1 = 8.
Lexi made the mistake of rounding down (or truncating) 7.2 to 7, which leaves 2 students without a supervisor. In this type of real-world problem, you must always round up to ensure everyone is accounted for.
Common mistakes
✗ Just saying "she rounded wrong" without explaining why it should be rounded up.
✗ Stating the correct answer is 8 without explaining what is wrong with Lexi's reasoning.
Practice the full AQA GCSE Maths Higher Tier Paper 3 Calculator
32 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01Work out the reciprocal of 10/3. Give your answer as a decimal.EasyQ02.1The table shows information about the number of houses with solar panels in a town. Complete the ...EasyQ02.2Use the graph to estimate the number of houses with solar panels in 2023.EasyQ03.1A building in the shape of a cylinder has diameter 40 m and height 55 m. On the centimetre grid, ...MediumQ03.2On this centimetre grid, draw the front elevation of the building. Use a scale of 1 cm to 10 m.Medium
Expert