Hard12 marksExtended Response
FamiliesFamiliesGender RolesFeminismSymmetrical Family

AQA GCSE · Question 11 · Families

Discuss how far sociologists would agree that gender roles are equal in families in Britain today.

How to approach this question

Structure your answer as a debate. 1. **Introduction:** State that there is a debate between the 'march of progress' view and the feminist view. 2. **Arguments FOR equality (March of Progress):** Explain the concept of the 'symmetrical family' (Young and Willmott). Mention the 'new man' and changes in attitudes and female employment. 3. **Arguments AGAINST equality (Feminism):** Explain the feminist critique. Use concepts like the 'double shift' or 'dual burden' (Ann Oakley). Mention that women still do more housework and emotional work. Discuss power and decision-making. 4. **Conclusion:** Summarise the arguments and decide 'how far' roles are equal. A good conclusion will state that while there has been progress, significant inequalities remain, so full equality has not been reached.

Full Answer

The extent to which gender roles have become equal in families in Britain today is a major topic of debate among sociologists. While there has been significant progress towards equality, many would argue that traditional inequalities persist. Some sociologists, such as Young and Willmott, would argue that gender roles have become much more equal. In their concept of the 'symmetrical family', they suggested that the roles of husbands and wives are becoming more similar and shared. This includes shared responsibility for housework, childcare, and decision-making, as well as both partners being in paid work. This 'march of progress' view is supported by evidence of changing attitudes, increased female employment, and men taking a more active role in fatherhood. The rise of the 'new man' who is more in touch with his feminine side and willing to do domestic chores supports this view. However, feminist sociologists would strongly disagree with this optimistic view. Ann Oakley, for example, was highly critical of Young and Willmott's research, arguing that their claims of symmetry were exaggerated. Her own research found that women still did the vast majority of housework and childcare, even when they also had full-time jobs, leading to the 'double shift'. More recent studies have supported this, finding that while men do more than in the past, women still shoulder the main burden of domestic tasks and especially the 'emotional work' of the family. Furthermore, feminists point out that key decisions, especially financial ones, are often still made by men, reflecting underlying power inequalities. Another point to consider is the impact of social class and ethnicity. The experience of gender roles can vary significantly. For example, some studies suggest that middle-class couples may have more egalitarian relationships than working-class couples, partly due to the ability to afford childcare and cleaners. Therefore, it is difficult to generalise about all families in Britain. In conclusion, while sociologists would agree that gender roles are more equal than they were in the past, most would argue that true equality has not yet been achieved. The 'march of progress' view appears overly optimistic when confronted with feminist evidence of the persistent 'double shift' and unequal decision-making. Therefore, sociologists would largely disagree with the statement, suggesting that while roles have changed, a significant gender gap in domestic labour and power remains.
This question centres on the 'march of progress' versus the feminist perspective on the family. The 'march of progress' view, associated with functionalists and sociologists like Young and Willmott, sees the modern family as evolving towards greater equality and symmetry. They argue that industrialisation and changing social norms have led to more democratic and companionate relationships. In contrast, feminists argue that the family remains a patriarchal institution. They provide evidence that women continue to bear the primary responsibility for domestic and emotional labour, and that power imbalances persist, often manifesting in areas like finance and domestic abuse.

Common mistakes

A common mistake is to only describe one side of the argument. The question requires a discussion, so both the 'march of progress' and feminist views must be presented and evaluated. Another error is making assertions without supporting them with sociological evidence or concepts.

Practice the full AQA GCSE Sociology Paper 1

22 questions · hints · full answers · grading

More questions from this exam