Medium1 markStructured
OrganisationHigherdata interpretationplant biology

AQA GCSE · Question 01.4 · Organisation

Table 1Part of deadly nightshade plantMass of chemical A in 100 g of plant tissue in gramsRoots1.3Leaves1.2Berries0.7

Scientists have extracted chemical A from the deadly nightshade plant. Chemical A can be used as a painkiller. Table 1 shows information about where chemical A is found. The scientists usually extract chemical A from the berries of the deadly nightshade plant. Suggest one reason why berries are used instead of leaves or roots.

How to approach this question

Look at the data in Table 1. Notice that berries contain the *least* amount of chemical A per 100g. Therefore, the reason for using them cannot be about yield. Think about the practicalities of harvesting different parts of a plant and the sustainability of the process.

Full Answer

Berries are used because they are easier/safer to harvest than roots, or to avoid killing the plant.
The table shows that roots and leaves contain a higher concentration of chemical A (1.3g and 1.2g per 100g respectively) compared to berries (0.7g per 100g). Therefore, the reason for using berries is not based on getting the most chemical A per gram of tissue. A practical reason is that harvesting berries is much easier and less destructive than digging up roots. Harvesting roots would kill the plant, whereas harvesting berries allows the plant to survive and produce more berries in the future, making it a more sustainable practice.

Common mistakes

✗ Stating that berries contain the most chemical A (this is incorrect according to the table). ✗ Stating it is cheaper, without explaining why (e.g., easier harvesting reduces labour costs). The reason needs to be biological or practical.

Practice the full AQA GCSE Biology Higher Tier Paper 1

52 questions · hints · full answers · grading

More questions from this exam