Medium4 marksStructured
AQA GCSE · Question 03.4 · Life in Modern Britain
SOURCE C:
Making sanctions effective
Sanctions are a method to resolving international disputes and conflicts. However, some criticise them for not being effective because:
• those in power, in countries against which sanctions are operated, may respond by becoming more oppressive; those who oppose their rule are often targeted
• sanctions often hurt the poor and not those in power
• sanctions are not enforced consistently.
QUESTION:
With reference to Source C, discuss how sanctions could be made more effective.
SOURCE C:
Making sanctions effective
Sanctions are a method to resolving international disputes and conflicts. However, some criticise them for not being effective because:
• those in power, in countries against which sanctions are operated, may respond by becoming more oppressive; those who oppose their rule are often targeted
• sanctions often hurt the poor and not those in power
• sanctions are not enforced consistently.
QUESTION:
With reference to Source C, discuss how sanctions could be made more effective.
How to approach this question
Read Source C and identify the criticisms of sanctions. For each criticism, think about the opposite action. This will give you a way to make them more effective. For example, if they hurt the poor, how can you change them to not hurt the poor? If they are not enforced consistently, what is the solution? Use the source to frame your answer.
Full Answer
One way to make sanctions more effective is to ensure they target those in power, not the general population. The source states that 'sanctions often hurt the poor and not those in power'. Therefore, 'smart sanctions' could be used, such as freezing the foreign bank accounts of specific government leaders or banning them from international travel, which would pressure the leadership directly without harming ordinary citizens.
A second way, based on the source, is to enforce them consistently. The source criticises that 'sanctions are not enforced consistently'. To make them more effective, a united international approach is needed where all major countries agree to and enforce the same sanctions. This would prevent the targeted country from simply trading with other nations that are not participating, thus increasing the economic pressure.
The question requires using the source to suggest improvements to the use of economic sanctions. The source provides three key weaknesses. A good answer will address two of these. For example, to counter the problem of hurting the poor, one could advocate for 'smart sanctions' that target the assets of the ruling elite. To counter inconsistent enforcement, one could argue for stronger international agreements and monitoring through bodies like the UN Security Council. To counter the risk of making regimes more oppressive, sanctions could be combined with diplomatic support for opposition groups.
Common mistakes
Students might just re-state the problems from the source without explaining the solutions. For example, just saying 'they should be enforced consistently' without explaining *why* this would make them more effective.
Practice the full AQA GCSE Citizenship Studies Paper 2
28 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01.1Why is tolerance an important value in modern Britain?
Shade in the one correct answer.
Because...EasyQ01.2Using one example, explain the term 'rule of law'.EasyQ01.3SOURCE A:
The key British value of democracy
Democracy is a key British value. However, in 2020 ...MediumQ02.1What does 'freedom of the press' mean?
Shade in the one correct answer.
Newspapers should be fr...EasyQ02.2Explain the term 'citizen journalist'.Easy
Expert