Hard6 marksExtended Response

AQA GCSE · Question 05 · Ethical legal and environmental impacts of digital technology

An autonomous vehicle is controlled by a computer system, senses its environment and requires no input from a human driver.

Discuss the legal and ethical impacts that need to be considered when replacing manual, human-driven vehicles with autonomous vehicles.

How to approach this question

Structure your answer into two parts: legal impacts and ethical impacts. - **For legal impacts**, think about laws, rules, and who is held responsible. What happens when something goes wrong? Who is to blame in an accident? What about the data the car collects? - **For ethical impacts**, think about what is right and wrong. Consider difficult choices the car's AI might have to make. Think about the effect on people's jobs and society as a whole. - For each point, state the issue and then explain *why* it is a problem or something that needs to be considered. Try to provide at least two points for each category.

Full Answer

There are significant legal and ethical impacts to consider with the adoption of autonomous vehicles. **Legal Impacts:** A key legal issue is **liability in case of an accident**. If an autonomous car causes a crash, who is at fault? Is it the owner, the manufacturer of the car, or the developer of the software? Current laws are based on human drivers being in control, so new legislation is required to clarify accountability. There are also issues around **data privacy**, as autonomous vehicles collect vast amounts of data about location, routes, and even conversations inside the car. Laws will be needed to govern who owns this data and how it can be used. **Ethical Impacts:** A major ethical dilemma is **algorithmic decision-making in no-win scenarios**. For example, if a car must choose between hitting a group of pedestrians or swerving and harming its occupant, how should it be programmed to decide? Different ethical frameworks (e.g., utilitarianism) could lead to different outcomes, and there is no universal agreement on the "correct" choice. Another impact is **job displacement**. Millions of people work as professional drivers (taxis, lorries, buses), and widespread adoption of autonomous vehicles could lead to mass unemployment in this sector, raising ethical questions about societal responsibility to these workers. Finally, there is an ethical concern about **over-reliance on technology**, which could lead to a degradation of human driving skills and an inability to take over in an emergency.
The introduction of autonomous vehicles (AVs) presents complex challenges that go beyond technology, touching on fundamental legal and ethical principles. **Legal Impacts:** The most significant legal question is **accountability and liability**. In a crash involving a human driver, fault is assigned based on their actions. With an AV, the lines are blurred. Is the owner responsible, even if they weren't driving? Is the car manufacturer liable for a hardware failure? Or is the software company that programmed the AI to blame for a poor decision? Existing legal frameworks are inadequate for this, and new laws are needed to define liability. Furthermore, AVs generate enormous amounts of data, including location tracking, video footage, and driving habits. This raises **data privacy and security** concerns. Legislation must be created to control who can access this data and for what purpose, and to establish penalties for data breaches or misuse. **Ethical Impacts:** The most debated ethical issue is the **"trolley problem" of programming accident scenarios**. AVs will face situations where a collision is unavoidable. The AI will have to make a split-second choice, for example, between hitting pedestrians or swerving to risk the life of its passenger. How this decision is programmed is an ethical minefield. Should it prioritize the many over the few (utilitarianism)? Should it always protect the owner? There is no global consensus. Another major ethical concern is **mass unemployment**. The transport and logistics industries employ millions of drivers. The widespread adoption of AVs could automate these jobs away, leading to significant social and economic disruption. Society has an ethical responsibility to consider how to manage this transition, potentially through retraining programs or social safety nets.

Common mistakes

✗ Only discussing advantages or disadvantages of the technology itself (e.g., "they are safer"). ✗ Confusing legal and ethical issues. ✗ Not providing enough detail or explanation for the points raised. ✗ Simply stating "the trolley problem" without explaining what it is or why it's relevant.

Practice the full AQA GCSE Computer Science Paper 2

46 questions · hints · full answers · grading

More questions from this exam