Hard34 marksExtended Response
AQA GCSE · Question 01 · Modern Texts and Poetry
JB Priestley: An Inspector Calls
Mr Birling says, '...a man has to mind his own business and look after himself and his own'.
How far does Priestley present Mr Birling as a man who cares only for himself and his family?
Write about:
• what Mr Birling says and does
• how far Priestley presents Mr Birling as a man who cares only for himself and his family.
JB Priestley: An Inspector Calls
Mr Birling says, '...a man has to mind his own business and look after himself and his own'.
How far does Priestley present Mr Birling as a man who cares only for himself and his family?
Write about:
• what Mr Birling says and does
• how far Priestley presents Mr Birling as a man who cares only for himself and his family.
How to approach this question
1. **Introduction:** State your argument in response to the question. Agree that Priestley presents Mr Birling as selfish, and briefly outline the points you will make (his capitalist views, his treatment of Eva Smith, his reaction to the Inspector's revelations).
2. **Paragraph 1 (Capitalist Ideology):** Analyse the quote provided in the question. Discuss how his speeches at the start of the play establish his character as arrogant, complacent, and a mouthpiece for capitalist self-interest. Use quotes like 'a man has to mind his own business' and his dismissal of 'community and all that nonsense'.
3. **Paragraph 2 (Actions towards Eva Smith):** Discuss his sacking of Eva Smith for asking for a small pay rise. Explain how this action demonstrates his priority of profit over people's welfare. Link this to his lack of social responsibility.
4. **Paragraph 3 (Reaction to the Inspector):** Analyse how Mr Birling's main concern throughout the inspection is to protect his reputation and avoid a 'public scandal'. Discuss his attempts to intimidate the Inspector and his relief when he believes it was a hoax.
5. **Paragraph 4 (Family Concern):** Explore the idea that his concern for his family is also tied to his own self-interest. For example, his concern about Sheila's engagement is partly about the business merger between Birling and Co. and Crofts Limited.
6. **Conclusion:** Summarise your points, reiterating that Priestley uses Mr Birling as a symbol of the selfish individualism he believed was damaging society. Conclude that he is presented as a character who fails to learn the Inspector's lesson of collective responsibility.
Full Answer
A strong answer will argue that Priestley presents Mr Birling as a character who predominantly cares for himself and his immediate family, using him to critique capitalist and individualistic ideologies. The response should analyse his dialogue, actions, and interactions with the Inspector and his family to support this argument. It should also consider moments where his concern for 'his own' might be seen as a natural parental instinct, but ultimately conclude that his motivations are rooted in self-preservation, social status, and financial gain, rather than genuine altruism or social responsibility.
This question assesses your ability to analyse characterisation and theme in 'An Inspector Calls'. J.B. Priestley uses Mr Birling as an embodiment of the selfish capitalist ideology that he criticised. Your essay should explore how Birling's words and actions consistently prioritise personal gain and social status over the welfare of others, making him a foil to the Inspector's socialist message of collective responsibility.
Common mistakes
A common mistake is simply listing things Mr Birling does without analysing *how* Priestley presents him. Avoid just retelling the story. Instead, focus on Priestley's techniques (dialogue, dramatic irony, stage directions) and the effect they have on the audience's perception of the character.
Practice the full AQA GCSE English Literature Paper 2
28 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q02JB Priestley: An Inspector Calls
How far does Priestley present male characters as irresponsible...HardQ25SOURCE TEXT:
Walking Away
It is eighteen years ago, almost to the day –
A sunny day with leaves ...HardQ26SOURCE TEXT:
Remains
On another occasion, we get sent out
to tackle looters raiding a bank.
And ...HardQ27.1SOURCE TEXT:
I Am Offering this Poem
I am offering this poem to you,
since I have nothing else t...HardQ27.2SOURCE TEXT:
First Light
The sun has burst the sky,
And spilled its gold on you.
My world, once ...Medium
Expert