Medium3 marksStructured
AQA GCSE · Question 03.4 · Infection and Response
The scientists incubated the bacteria at 37 °C. Students in school laboratories incubate bacteria at 25 °C. Explain why scientists use 37 °C but students must use 25 °C to incubate bacteria.
The scientists incubated the bacteria at 37 °C. Students in school laboratories incubate bacteria at 25 °C. Explain why scientists use 37 °C but students must use 25 °C to incubate bacteria.
How to approach this question
Your explanation needs two parts:
1. Why is 37 °C a good temperature for professional scientists to use for this specific experiment? (Think about the bacteria's natural environment).
2. Why is 37 °C a *bad* temperature for students to use in a school lab? (Think about safety).
Full Answer
Scientists use 37 °C because it is the optimum temperature for the growth of human pathogens like Salmonella, as it is human body temperature. This allows for rapid growth and quick results. Students in schools must use 25 °C as a safety precaution. This lower temperature reduces the risk of growing harmful human pathogens, which thrive at 37 °C.
**Why scientists use 37 °C:**
Scientists in professional laboratories use an incubation temperature of 37 °C because this is human body temperature. Pathogenic bacteria that infect humans, such as *Salmonella*, are adapted to thrive at this temperature. Using 37 °C ensures the bacteria grow at their optimal rate, leading to faster results for their investigation.
**Why students use 25 °C:**
In a school laboratory, safety is the primary concern. Incubating cultures at 37 °C would create the perfect conditions for the growth of potentially dangerous human pathogens. To minimise this risk, schools have a strict rule to incubate at a lower temperature, typically 25 °C. While bacteria will still grow, this temperature is significantly lower than the optimum for most human pathogens, greatly reducing the chance of culturing a harmful microbe to dangerous levels.
Common mistakes
✗ Stating that no pathogens can grow at 25 °C (some can, but growth is much slower).
✗ Confusing the reason for scientists (speed/optimum growth) with the reason for students (safety).
✗ Just saying "it's safer" without explaining *why* it is safer (reduces risk of growing harmful pathogens).
Practice the full AQA GCSE Biology Higher Tier Paper 1
52 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01.1A root is a plant organ. Plant roots contain many different types of tissue. What is a tissue?EasyQ01.2Tissue in the tip of a plant root contains stem cells. Stem cells can differentiate into any type...EasyQ01.3In the past many drugs were extracted from plants. Aspirin is a painkiller. Which plant does aspi...EasyQ01.4Scientists have extracted chemical A from the deadly nightshade plant. Chemical A can be used as ...MediumQ01.5A deadly nightshade plant has chlorosis (yellow leaves). The mass of chemical A found in the leav...Medium
Expert