Hard8 marksExtended Response
AQA GCSE · Question 05.2 · Life in Modern Britain
'British citizens have a duty to participate in democracy even if they feel apathetic about politics.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
• the political rights and duties of British citizens
• issues relating to voter apathy.
'British citizens have a duty to participate in democracy even if they feel apathetic about politics.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
• the political rights and duties of British citizens
• issues relating to voter apathy.
How to approach this question
Structure your answer with an introduction, arguments for, arguments against, and a conclusion. Use the bullet points as a guide. For the 'agree' side, discuss why participation is a duty. For the 'disagree' side, discuss why it's a right and explore the reasons for voter apathy. In your conclusion, weigh the arguments and state your own justified view on the extent to which you agree.
Full Answer
A good answer will present a balanced argument, considering the arguments for and against the idea of a duty to participate, before reaching a justified conclusion.
Arguments agreeing with the statement (there is a duty to participate):
- Participation, especially voting, is a civic duty. People in the past fought and died for the right to vote, so we have a responsibility to use it. By voting, we give legitimacy to the government that is elected.
- If citizens do not participate, decisions will be made by a small, unrepresentative group of people. To ensure the government reflects the will of the whole population, everyone needs to take part. This is part of the social contract.
- Not participating can lead to governments that ignore the needs of large parts of the population, particularly the young or the poor who tend to have lower turnout. Participation is a way of holding power to account.
Arguments disagreeing with the statement (there is no duty to participate):
- Voting is a right, not a duty. The right to freedom of choice includes the right *not* to vote. Forcing people to participate who are apathetic or uninformed could lead to poor decisions or random votes.
- Voter apathy is often a symptom of a broken political system. People may feel that no party represents their views, that their vote won't make a difference (e.g., in a safe seat), or they may be disillusioned with politicians. In this case, not voting can be a form of political protest.
- There are other ways to participate in democracy besides voting, such as signing petitions, protesting, or joining a pressure group. A citizen might be politically active in these ways while choosing not to vote in an election.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, while I understand the view that voting is a right that can be freely chosen not to be exercised, I largely agree with the statement. The health of a democracy depends on the active participation of its citizens. While apathy is often understandable, abstaining from the process cedes power to others and weakens the principle of government by the people. Therefore, citizens have a strong moral, if not legal, duty to engage in the democratic process, at the very least by casting a vote, to ensure the government is as representative and accountable as possible.
This question asks for an evaluation of the concept of civic duty in relation to democratic participation. A strong answer will explore the tension between individual rights (the right to abstain) and collective responsibility (the duty to contribute to the democratic process). It should acknowledge the valid reasons for voter apathy (e.g., disillusionment, lack of representation) while also considering the consequences of non-participation (e.g., unrepresentative governments, weakened democracy). The conclusion should synthesise these points into a coherent personal judgement.
Common mistakes
Students may focus too much on just voter apathy without discussing the wider concept of rights and duties. It is also a mistake to not offer a clear conclusion that states the extent of agreement or disagreement.
Practice the full AQA GCSE Citizenship Studies Paper 2
28 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01.1Why is tolerance an important value in modern Britain?
Shade in the one correct answer.
Because...EasyQ01.2Using one example, explain the term 'rule of law'.EasyQ01.3SOURCE A:
The key British value of democracy
Democracy is a key British value. However, in 2020 ...MediumQ02.1What does 'freedom of the press' mean?
Shade in the one correct answer.
Newspapers should be fr...EasyQ02.2Explain the term 'citizen journalist'.Easy
Expert