Easy2 marksExtended Response
AQA GCSE · Question 06 · Cognition and Behaviour
Explain one weakness of the reconstructive theory of memory.
Explain one weakness of the reconstructive theory of memory.
How to approach this question
Identify a valid weakness of the theory. Then, provide a brief explanation of why it is a weakness. A good structure is to state the point (e.g., it's not very scientific) and then elaborate on it (e.g., because schemas cannot be directly measured).
Full Answer
One weakness is that the theory may be too vague and difficult to test scientifically. The concept of 'schemas' is not directly observable or measurable, which makes it hard to prove their existence or how they influence memory. This lack of empirical testability reduces the scientific credibility of the theory.
While influential, Bartlett's theory has weaknesses. A key criticism is its lack of scientific rigour. Bartlett's own research methods were informal and lacked the controls of modern experiments. More fundamentally, the core concept of a 'schema' is abstract and cannot be directly observed or measured, making it difficult to design experiments to test the theory's predictions precisely. Another weakness is that the theory can be seen as focusing too much on the inaccuracies of memory, without adequately explaining how we are often able to recall events with a high degree of accuracy.
Common mistakes
Stating a weakness without explaining it. For example, just saying 'it is unscientific' is not enough for full marks.
Practice the full AQA GCSE Psychology Paper 1
37 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01Which is the best example of information that would be stored as procedural memory?EasyQ02Which of the following statements about short-term memory (STM) is true?EasyQ03Evaluate the multi-store model of memory.HardQ04Describe Bartlett's 'War of the Ghosts' study.MediumQ05Read the following information.
A police officer is reading the statements of two eyewitnesses. ...Hard
Expert