Medium4 marksExtended Response
Cognition and BehaviourPerceptionFactors Affecting PerceptionCultureApplication

AQA GCSE · Question 13 · Cognition and Behaviour

A psychologist carried out a laboratory experiment to see whether or not culture affects perception. He asked Marc and José to look at the three images shown in Figure 2 (a sheep, some grass, and a cat) and decide which image was the odd one out.

Marc was brought up on a farm and still lives in a rural part of France. Marc said, "The cat is the odd one out. The sheep and the grass go together best because sheep eat grass.”

José was brought up in the Spanish city where he still lives. “No!” said José, "it's the grass. The cat and the sheep go together best because they are both animals."

Outline how culture can affect perception. Refer to both Marc and José's comments in your answer.

How to approach this question

1. Start by defining or explaining how culture can affect perception in general (e.g., by shaping how we categorise things). 2. Apply this concept to Marc. Explain why his rural/farming culture led him to group the sheep and grass together (a relational link). Refer directly to his comment. 3. Apply the concept to José. Explain why his urban/city culture led him to group the cat and sheep together (a categorical link). Refer directly to his comment. 4. Conclude by summarising that their different cultural backgrounds caused them to perceive the relationships between the objects differently.

Full Answer

Culture, the shared beliefs, values, and experiences of a group, can affect perception by influencing how we interpret and categorise information from the world around us. This is a top-down process where our cultural background shapes our perceptual set. Marc, who has a rural farming background, perceives the items based on their functional relationship. His culture and experience have taught him to see the connection between a sheep and the grass it eats. Therefore, he groups 'sheep' and 'grass' together and sees the 'cat' as the odd one out. José, from a city background, perceives the items based on their taxonomic category. His culture and education likely emphasised grouping things by what they are. He sees that a 'cat' and a 'sheep' are both animals, so he groups them together. This makes the 'grass', which is a plant, the odd one out for him. Their different cultural experiences have led them to perceive and categorise the same three images in different ways.
This scenario illustrates how culture influences cognitive processes, including perception and categorisation. Research has shown that people from collectivist or rural cultures (like Marc's) often tend to think holistically, focusing on relationships and context. They group objects based on functional relationships (e.g., 'sheep eat grass'). In contrast, people from individualistic or urban/Western cultures (like José's) often tend to think analytically, focusing on objects and their attributes. They are more likely to group objects based on abstract taxonomic categories (e.g., 'sheep and cats are both animals'). Marc's and José's different responses to the same perceptual task demonstrate the powerful top-down influence of their cultural upbringing on how they interpret the world.

Common mistakes

Simply repeating what Marc and José said without explaining the underlying cultural reasons. Not referring to both individuals. Providing a vague explanation without using terms like 'category' or 'relationship'.

Practice the full AQA GCSE Psychology Paper 1

37 questions · hints · full answers · grading

More questions from this exam