Medium2 marksStructured
AQA GCSE · Question 03.5 · Bioenergetics
A farmer decided not to use a concentration of carbon dioxide higher than 0.08% to grow tomato plants.
Suggest two reasons for the farmer's decision. Use information from Table 2 and your own knowledge.
A farmer decided not to use a concentration of carbon dioxide higher than 0.08% to grow tomato plants.
Suggest two reasons for the farmer's decision. Use information from Table 2 and your own knowledge.
How to approach this question
1. **Look at the data** in Table 2 for concentrations above 0.08% (i.e., 0.10% and 0.12%). What happens to the rate of photosynthesis? This is your first reason.
2. **Think like a farmer.** Farmers want to maximise their profit. Pumping extra CO2 into a greenhouse costs money. If the extra CO2 doesn't increase the rate of photosynthesis (and therefore the growth of tomatoes), what is the financial implication? This is your second reason.
Full Answer
1. The rate of photosynthesis does not increase (it plateaus) above 0.08% CO2 concentration.
2. It would be a waste of money / too expensive to add more CO2 for no extra growth.
1. **Evidence from the table:** The table shows that at 0.08% CO2, the rate of photosynthesis is 20 arbitrary units. At 0.10% and 0.12%, the rate remains at 20. This means that increasing the CO2 beyond 0.08% has no further effect on the rate of photosynthesis. The rate has plateaued, likely because another factor (such as light intensity or temperature) has become the limiting factor.
2. **Economic reason:** To increase the CO2 concentration in a commercial greenhouse, a farmer would need to buy and burn fuel (like paraffin heaters) or use cylinders of CO2 gas, both of which cost money. Since there is no increase in the rate of photosynthesis (and therefore no faster growth or bigger yield of tomatoes) above 0.08%, spending money on extra CO2 would be uneconomical and would reduce the farmer's profit.
Common mistakes
✗ Not using the data from the table for the first point.\n✗ Suggesting that higher CO2 levels might harm the plant (the data does not support this).\n✗ Giving two very similar reasons, e.g., "it costs money" and "it's expensive".
Practice the full AQA GCSE Biology Foundation Tier Paper 1
60 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01.1HIV (Human Immunodeficiency Virus) is a pathogen.
How is HIV spread from one person to another p...EasyQ01.2**Table 1** shows information about new cases of HIV diagnosed in the UK.
Describe what happened...MediumQ01.3What could cause a **decrease** in the number of new HIV cases in the future?
Tick (✔) one box.EasyQ01.4Scientists have been working to produce a vaccine for HIV for many years.
How could a vaccine wo...MediumQ01.5When scientists produce a vaccine for a disease the vaccine is tested on live animals.
What is t...Easy
Expert