Medium4 marksExtended Response
Cognition and BehaviourDevelopmentPiaget's TheoryEgocentrismHughes' Study

AQA GCSE · Question 20 · Cognition and Behaviour

Hughes investigated egocentrism in his 'policeman doll study'. Describe this study.

How to approach this question

Structure your answer by describing the key features of the study: Aim, Procedure, Results, and Conclusion (APRC). 1. **Aim:** What was Hughes trying to find out? (A better test for egocentrism). 2. **Procedure:** Who were the participants (young children)? What materials were used (model walls, dolls)? What did the children have to do? 3. **Results:** What were the main findings? (A high percentage of children succeeded). 4. **Conclusion:** What did Hughes conclude from these results? (Children are less egocentric than Piaget thought).

Full Answer

Hughes' (1975) study aimed to create a test for egocentrism that made more sense to children than Piaget's three mountains task. The procedure involved showing children aged 3.5 to 5 a model of two intersecting walls that formed a cross shape, creating four sections. The child was introduced to two policeman dolls and one 'boy' doll. The child was first asked to hide the boy doll from one policeman. After they could do this, a second policeman doll was introduced. The key task was for the child to hide the boy doll in a section where neither of the two policeman dolls could see him. Hughes found that 90% of the children were able to correctly hide the boy doll from both policemen. He concluded that children are able to see the world from another person's perspective at a younger age than Piaget suggested, as long as the task is meaningful and makes sense to them.
Martin Hughes' 'policeman doll study' was a direct challenge to Piaget's findings on egocentrism from the 'three mountains task'. Piaget concluded that children in the pre-operational stage were egocentric, meaning they could not see a situation from another's point of view. Hughes argued that the three mountains task was too abstract and unfamiliar for young children. He designed his study to be more like a game the children could understand. The task required the child to take into account two different points of view simultaneously (that of each policeman). The high success rate (90%) strongly suggested that Piaget had underestimated children's abilities and that they could overcome egocentrism much earlier when the task made 'human sense'.

Common mistakes

Confusing this study with Piaget's three mountains task. Being vague about the procedure or the results. Forgetting the key finding that 90% of children succeeded.

Practice the full AQA GCSE Psychology Paper 1

37 questions · hints · full answers · grading

More questions from this exam