Hard5 marksExtended Response
The Human Body and Movement in Physical Activity and SportTraining MethodsAltitude TrainingEndurance
AQA GCSE · Question 17 · The Human Body and Movement in Physical Activity and Sport
Performers may train at high altitude. This usually takes place at over 2000 m above sea level for at least 30 days.
Discuss whether altitude training is an effective method of training for a long-distance swimmer.
Performers may train at high altitude. This usually takes place at over 2000 m above sea level for at least 30 days.
Discuss whether altitude training is an effective method of training for a long-distance swimmer.
How to approach this question
Structure your answer as a balanced discussion.
1. Start by explaining the benefits of altitude training. Describe the physiological process (less oxygen -> more red blood cells) and explain why this would help a long-distance swimmer (improved oxygen transport, better endurance).
2. Next, discuss the drawbacks. Explain the negative impact on training intensity, the practical difficulties (cost, sickness), and how this might affect performance.
3. Conclude with a summary statement that weighs the pros and cons to answer the 'discuss' part of the question.
Full Answer
Altitude training is a method used by endurance athletes to improve performance. The discussion of its effectiveness for a long-distance swimmer involves weighing its pros and cons.
**Arguments for Effectiveness (Advantages):**
- The primary benefit comes from adapting to the 'hypoxic' (low oxygen) environment. The body responds by increasing the production of the hormone erythropoietin (EPO), which stimulates the bone marrow to produce more red blood cells.
- More red blood cells mean more haemoglobin, which increases the blood's oxygen-carrying capacity.
- Upon returning to sea level, the athlete has a higher concentration of red blood cells. This allows for more efficient oxygen delivery to the muscles, enhancing their VO2 max and aerobic endurance, and delaying the onset of fatigue. This is a significant advantage in long-distance swimming.
**Arguments against Effectiveness (Disadvantages):**
- The lack of oxygen at altitude makes it impossible to train at the same high intensity as at sea level. For a swimmer, this could mean slower swim times in training, potentially leading to a loss of 'feel' for the water and a detriment to race-pace technique.
- There are significant practical challenges, including the high cost of travel and accommodation, the time commitment (at least 3-4 weeks), and the risk of developing altitude sickness, which can ruin a training block.
- The physiological benefits are not permanent and will diminish over time once back at sea level.
**Conclusion:** Altitude training can be highly effective for improving a long-distance swimmer's aerobic capacity. However, these benefits must be carefully balanced against the risk of reduced training intensity and the significant logistical challenges. A 'live high, train low' approach, where the athlete lives at altitude but travels to a lower elevation to train, is often considered the optimal but most complex solution.
Common mistakes
Only listing advantages and not providing a balanced discussion. Not linking the physiological adaptations directly to the demands of long-distance swimming.
Practice the full AQA GCSE Physical Education Paper 1
34 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01Which one of these components of fitness is the most important when dribbling a ball around a def...EasyQ02Which one of these is the correct pathway of the blood in the cardiac cycle as it returns to the ...EasyQ03Which one of these bones is located at the shoulder joint?EasyQ04A sprinter includes speed work in their training.
Which one of these principles of training are ...EasyQ05Table 1 shows the ratings of a GCSE PE class for the Vertical Jump Test.
**Table 1**
| Rating ...Easy
Expert